The list of preventive services that women can receive without paying anything out of pocket could grow if draft recommendations by an expert panel are adopted by federal officials this year.
The draft recommendations, which are subject to public comment until Sept. 30, build upon and add to the eight recommended preventive services for women now covered by insurers for no out-of-pocket cost. As a result of the health law, the initial list was developed in 2012 by the Institute of Medicine — now called the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. It requires most health plans to cover well-woman visits, screening and/or counseling for sexually transmitted infections, domestic violence and gestational diabetes as well as breastfeeding support and supplies.
In addition, most health plans are required to cover, without cost sharing, all methods of contraception that have been approved by the Food and Drug Administration. That controversial requirement led to numerous lawsuits by religious institutions and employers that object to providing such coverage, including several cases that reached the Supreme Court.
When it developed the initial list, the IOM advised that the guidelines be reviewed and updated at least every five years to stay current with scientific evidence.
This year, an expert review panel weighed in on breast cancer screening, male methods of birth control and coverage of follow-up testing or procedures stemming from preventive services. The American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) was awarded a 5-year grant to manage the review process, working with nearly two dozen provider groups from different women’s health disciplines.
The panel proposed to allow women at average risk for breast cancer to begin screening as early as age 40 and receive a mammogram every one or two years. That’s consistent with current rules established by Congress, but it’s a more liberal standard than the guidelines from the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, which recommends women generally be screened every other year starting at age 50.
“We have really confused the heck out of women,” said Dr. Hal Lawrence, executive vice president and chief executive officer of ACOG. “Do I start at age 40, do I start at 50, do I do it every year or do I do it every other year? We wanted to get some uniformity.”
In addition to the breast cancer screening itself, the ACOG working group proposed that if imaging tests, biopsies or other interventions are required to evaluate the mammogram findings that those be considered an integral part of the screening, which would mean they would be provided without charge to women.
Such follow-up care emerged as a theme from the panel: If additional testing or procedures are necessary following a preventive service, it should be covered as part of the service. The recommendations also clarify that some of the preventive services may require more than one visit and provide other specifics on coverage requirements.
“It’s critically important for plans and people to recognize that the well-woman visit [required under the current guidelines] could happen in multiple places and require multiple visits,” said Mara Gandal-Powers, senior counsel at the National Women’s Law Center, which participated in the ACOG working group. “If you’re a woman who needs a Pap test and a colonoscopy, you’re probably not getting them from the same providers and you’re hopefully not getting them at the same time.”
The working group also recommended that the contraceptive coverage requirement extend to over-the-counter methods of birth control and allow women to receive a full-year supply of contraceptives all at once, which has been shown to improve adherence. In addition, the ACOG group proposed covering contraception methods used by men, including condoms and vasectomy.
“The best contraceptive method for a woman at a particular time may be her partner,” said Adam Sonfield, a senior policy manager at the Guttmacher Institute, a reproductive health research and policy organization.
The original IOM guidelines left implementation details vague, leading to disagreements between patient advocates and insurers over precisely what was covered, and that ambiguity required ongoing guidance from the federal government. For example, if a plan covers oral contraceptives without cost sharing, could it charge for other hormonal methods such as the contraceptive patch? (Answer: No.)
“It’s helpful to get the real-world piece,” said Dania Palanker, assistant research professor at Georgetown University’s Center on Health Insurance Reforms. “For insurers, what do we mean when we say you have to cover a service?”
A spokesperson for America’s Health Insurance Plans said that the trade group will likely submit comments on the recommendations and declined to comment before then.
The working group will submit its final recommendations to the Health Resources and Services Administration, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, by Dec. 1, and HRSA will make the final decision on the recommendations. If adopted before the end of the year, they would go into effect for most plans at the beginning of 2018.
This story has been updated to correct information about insurance coverage for mammograms. Although the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommends screening every other year starting at 50, Congress has said insurers should use a 2002 standard that recommends mammograms starting at age 40 every 1 to 2 years.
Please visit khn.org/columnists to send comments or ideas for future topics for the Insuring Your Health column.